Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza

Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza is a standout gem in New Milford, PA, serving up authentic Italian-inspired pizzas and subs that truly satisfy. Tucked comfortably at 914 Main St, this beloved family-owned pizza restaurant brings more than just food to the table—it offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere enriched by a staff whose fun and entertaining nature instantly makes you feel right at home.

Specializing in classic Italian-style pizzas crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients, Uncle Charlie’s Bella Pizza delivers an unforgettable taste experience. From the first bite, you’ll notice the perfect balance of a crisp, golden crust, robust tomato sauce, and generous layers of rich, gooey cheese. The aroma of freshly baked dough mingled with savory toppings is nothing short of irresistible. The menu doesn’t skimp on variety either, with deliciously made subs that rival even the best pizzerias in the region.

Many patrons rave about the unbeatable combination of quality and affordability here. Michael Frost sums it up perfectly, calling it “Best around” and praising the friendly staff who consistently add to the overall positive vibe. Bear Sayer’s enthusiastic endorsement highlights Uncle Charlie’s as the undisputed champion for both taste and freshness—a place so good, loyal customers won’t consider ordering pizza anywhere else.

While the food quality is exceptional, there’s also a genuine, down-to-earth charm that permeates the entire experience. Rebecca Vroman’s review captures this feeling, remarking on the owners and staff’s lively personalities, which make dining here as enjoyable as the food itself. The welcoming family atmosphere combined with excellent cuisine creates a spot that feels like an extension of your own dining room.

One practical note for visitors: Uncle Charlie’s operates on a cash-only basis, so be sure to bring cash with you as credit or debit cards are not accepted, and the ATM on site can be unreliable, as highlighted by Noel Read. However, this small inconvenience is easily overshadowed by the consistently stellar pizza and friendly service.

From the moment you place your order—whether eating in or taking out—you’ll sense the care and honesty that goes into every sandwich and pizza, just as Juan Miguez experienced during his visit. If you’re in the New Milford area craving a genuinely delicious, freshly made pizza with a side of genuine hospitality, Uncle Charlie’s Bella Pizza is not just a meal choice, but a happily memorable dining destination.